BAAJA Passes Senate

Big Permitting Bill passes Senate, going to the House where it will face some opposition, from incoming Speaker Hakeem Jeffries, among others.

Climate scientists generally in favor, with some exceptions. Noted climate warrior Senators like Senator Whitehouse, above, as well as Martin Heinrich, Brian Schatz, and John Hickenlooper, were supporters.

My take, after almost 10 years of involvement in clean energy siting at the local level, is, we need something to break the logjam on Transmission.

I reposted some of Zeke Hausfather’s correct observations:

Today more than 2,000 gigawatts of new power plants and batteries are waiting in line to connect to America’s electric grid. That is more than the capacity of every power plant now operating in the country, and about 85% of it is solar, wind and storage. Projects that came online in 2025 typically spent around 61 months in line waiting to be approved, up from 36 months in 2015.

Senator Martin Heinrich (D – New Mexico) on X:

In June, SunZia — the largest clean energy infrastructure project in the Western Hemisphere — came online in New Mexico after nearly two decades. The actual construction took just two years. That’s how badly our permitting system is holding America back. Americans sent Congress a clear message in this historic election: lower costs.

They’re tired of watching their electricity bills go up while some of the wealthiest corporations in the world get a free ride. We don’t have to wait another year to deliver relief. We can act right now. The Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act will get more affordable energy onto the grid faster, make data centers pay their fair share of electricity and grid costs, and create more than 100,000 good-paying American jobs — all while maintaining important environmental protections and strengthening Tribal consultation.

Wall Street Journal:

The two Republican no votes were Missouri’s Josh Hawley and South Dakota’s Mike Rounds. Mr. Hawley said the bill is “stuffed with giveaways to data centers and industry at the expense of farmers.” Did he read the bill? It includes several provisions to protect Americans from paying higher electricity rates to subsidize data centers.

Mr. Rounds objected because it allows the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission to override states to approve transmission lines. He’s right to worry that this provision could be abused, but FERC boasts this power to approve natural gas pipelines. Federalizing transmission authority was the price Republicans had to pay for Senate Democratic votes.

Heatmap:

The current Speaker of the House, Republican Mike Johnson of Louisiana, said earlier this week that he would try to pass BAAJA under suspension, a process that would send it straight to the floor for a vote the week after Thanksgiving. But a successful suspension vote would require a two-thirds majority of however many lawmakers actually show up, and since the midterms, many Republicans who lost their seats have checked out. House leadership canceled several votes this week after too few showed up to hold the party line.

—

Yale Climate Connections lists supporters, like Citizens Climate Lobby, AFL-CIO, American Petroleum Institute, and Edison Electric Institute, and detractors like Tribal Organizations, the Sierra Club, NAACP, and Natural Resources Defense Council, Al Gore, Bill Mckibben, and Mark Ruffalo.

First time ever I would side with American Petroleum Institute against Al Gore, but I believe we are in a Triage moment insofar as climate, and this is a bet we need to make.

The bet, and I’m in, is that if we make the overall permitting environment friendlier, the overwhelming number of new projects will be on the clean energy side. Exhibit number one would be Texas, where that is exactly what is happening, despite the best efforts of the Gas Lobby and the Texas legislature to stem the tide. Markets have been winning, and will continue to win.

One objection is that the bill purportedly would make siting Data centers easier, but from what I’m seeing that is not so. New York Times notes “Data centers would also have to pay much more for their electricity under a provision in the bill that would charge the facilities extra for access to the electric grid.” Data centers would be shouldering more of the electricity burden, shielding ratepayers.

That provision is a good step toward protecting ratepayers nationally, which will help avoid a race to the bottom, pitting state against state. Big concern I still have is that the bill does not compel the use of clean energy to power data centers, but again, I think all things being equal, quicker permitting of clean energy will make it compelling for Data developers to take that route and by pass the supply chain holdups for Gas, and development time for nuclear.

One thought on “BAAJA Passes Senate”

Leave a Reply