BAAJA Bill A Bet Worth Making

Despite misgivings on the part of many enviros, this bet is worth making, and I agree with Ezra Klein here.

Ezra Klein in New York Times:

While reporting on BAAJA, I talked to Bill McKibben, a climate writer and activist I greatly respect. The bill, he told me, “is plenty good enough for people in the clean energy industry, as they can live with and prosper under a regime where you’re steadily increasing the amount of clean energy, even if you’re increasing, or at least not quickly decreasing, the amount of fossil energy.” But he’s looking for something much more decisive, something that does not pose the risk of building more fossil fuel capacity.

McKibben’s theory is that the building El Niño and the war in Iran might unlock a political consensus to move far beyond fossil fuels in the near future. I don’t know if he’s right, but if he is, then BAAJA looks, to me, more like a risk worth taking. If you believe there’s going to be more pressure for decarbonization by 2029, you want to begin the process of making it easier to build green energy now. If Democrats then have so much power that they can pass more radical laws to help green energy, or impose a social cost on carbon emissions, then all the better. BAAJA can be a floor, not a ceiling. But even in his scenario, you need a new floor, and I don’t think we should wait years to start to build one.

The Senate vote to move forward on the bill was telling. Among Democrats from states that went for Kamala Harris by 10 points or more, the vote was 2-to-1 against it; among Democrats representing more purple or red states, it was 2-to-1 in favor. Something Senator Chuck Schumer said to me last week has been ringing in my ears: “If affordability doesn’t prevail, we’re in trouble,” he told me. “We cannot impose on people what we think is important. We have to listen to what’s important to them and then deliver.” (Schumer voted to advance the bill.)

Leave a Reply