Pass the BAAJA Permitting Bill

I spoke to Dana Nuccitelli last week, a climate scientist and old friend, former colleague at Yale Climate Connections.

Dana is doing some good work communicating on behalf of the Citizen’s Climate Lobby, in support of the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act, known as BAAJA, which Dems and Republicans are trying to get through the congress in the lame duck session. It passed its first legislative test last week.

90 percent of the energy projects held up in permitting processes are currently clean energy, or critically, transmission.  In many cases, those projects are being held up by laws originally written to protect the environment, some aspects of which are no longer fit for purpose in a time of climate change crisis.

Laws long cherished by Greenies such as myself, like the National Environmental policy act NEPA, and the Endangered species act, are being misused, at a moment when the biggest threat to the environment writ large as well as endangered species and biodiversity, is climate change  – and the solution is an energy transition, for which clean generation and transmission are critical.

Currently our ability to transmit energy generated in the heartland to population centers is inadequate.

It takes almost 18 years to permit a new interstate transmission line, and increasing amounts of clean electricity being generated in the country’s midwest, southwest, and great plains are being “curtailed” or wasted. In the Midwest Grid, known as MISO, energy equivalent to a large nuclear plant is being curtailed at any given moment due to lack of transmission.

Proponents of the BAAJA believe the if the playing field is leveled, clean energy will win out. The example they cite is Texas, where permitting is relatively simple and straightforward, and even in a very pro fossil fuel red state, market forces are choosing clean energy overwhelmingly.

Some have suggested that with the Blue wave election we have just had, we should wait until the new session and see if a bill can be written with fewer compromises.

Proponents point out that the current bill has been carefully negotiated to the limit of what might be acceptable to the White House.
It does contain some compromises that climate advocates will say are not ideal, including easier permitting for pipelines. The flaw there is that even if a bill more favorable to clean energy is written, Democrats would have to overcome a filibuster from Republicans. If the filibuster is revoked, which is uncertain, President Trump holds the veto pen for the next 2 years.


The problem we are trying to solve for is overcoming delays, and waiting for another 2 years minimum seems self defeating.

One continuing roadblock is building clean energy on federal land, which is made more difficult by regulations and potential for lawsuits that can hold up a project at any point.  Here is where adjustments in existing laws could be helpful.

Environmentalists argue correctly that this may cause some more pipeline infrastructure to be built, which could increase the exports of Liquified Natural Gas, LNG, definitely not a climate friendly fuel.

Here’s where the incompetence of the Trump administration might help us. Since the Iran War, countries all over the world, particularly the fastest growing economies in Asia and Africa, have been turning away from planned LNG projects, and from a dangerous dependence on the United States, which the Trump administration has shown to be an unreliable partner – to say nothing of the increasingly obvious impact of a changing climate. They are accelerating the deployment of ultra cheap solar power and batteries, which are rapidly dropping in price.

I believe there is significant risk to the gas industry of building what will become stranded assets as the transition accelerates. That’s part of the gamble.

One objection is that the BAAJA bill would accelerate the development of Data Centers, which might be powered by natural gas in a way that is counterproductive to climate goals.
But Michigan and Minnesota, among other states, have shown that significant guardrails can be applied to Data center development. Recent agreements with the Michigan Public Service commission will force two new large data centers in southeast Michigan to pay for their own grid connection, purchase, at their expense, new clean energy generation and storage sufficient to cover their demands, to be build across the state. A similar arrangement with Google has been negotiated in Minnesota.
BAAJA would formalize many of these same protections, and add some additional requirements,  nationally, which could make it less likely we’ll see a “race to the bottom” between states with more lax regulations.

My State of Michigan has been a leader in permitting reform, after a decade or more of frustrating delays for clean energy projects. This had been mostly due to bad faith actors spreading misinformation at the local level, where local boards were actually intimidated to pass illegal exclusionary ordinances.

In 2023, under Governor Whitmer’s leadership, the Democratic House and Senate passed PA 233, which provided an alternative permitting pathway at the state level. We see now that the log jam has been broken, and a surge of clean energy projects have now been permitted, with many more being planned and announced.

The hope is that with BAAJA, we can achieve a similar acceleration at the national level, and bring sufficient numbers of new projects on line to meaningfully move the needle on climate.

One thought on “Pass the BAAJA Permitting Bill”


  1. You are so wrong about this. So sad. It started well, but has been corrupted by vested interests who will use to to perpetuate big fossil projects and several of Trump’s pet corruptions. This will be a huge tragedy if it is not stopped.

Leave a Reply